Post Memories: Volunteers resurrect the voice of Titanic survivor

PUBLISHED: 13:00 17 April 2017

Esther/Eva Hart

Esther/Eva Hart


Titanic: The world knows the name, and it conjures up thoughts of a vast white ship, heartbreaking last embraces, and a Celine Dion soundtrack.

Esther/Eva Hart Esther/Eva Hart

But now people can hear the story of the world’s biggest ship from one of its oldest survivors, even though she passed away in 1996 and the ship herself sank 105 years ago.

Valence House discovered a recording of a talk in the old Barking Library by Eva Hart in the local archives, and volunteer Derek Alexander has had the recording copied professionally so the public can listen to her remarkable memories of that fateful voyage.

Eva Hart was born in Seven Kings in 1905, and her family’s finances suffered during the recession of 1911. A family friend from Canada persuaded her father, Benjamin Hart, to go into business with him in Winnipeg, where, he assured him, they would both become rich.

Eva’s “very down-to-earth and sensible” mother was unusually anxious of this overseas adventure, and tried to dissuade her husband.

Eva and Esther Hart, sentre and right, with an unknown woman, as they made their way back to England. Eva and Esther Hart, sentre and right, with an unknown woman, as they made their way back to England.

When asked why, she could only say: “I don’t know, only that we. must. not. do. it.”

A coal strike meant the family’s booking was changed from the ship the Philadelphia to the ill-fated vessel.

Benjamin was thrilled, exclaiming: “We’ve got a berth in the Titanic! Isn’t it wonderful? The whole world is talking about the Titanic.”

On the tape, Eva recalls her mother asking “isn’t that the ship they say is unsinkable?” and his reply: “No, dear, that’s the ship that is unsinkable.”

Eva Hart pub. PICTURE: Ewan Munro Eva Hart pub. PICTURE: Ewan Munro

His words, intended to reassure his uncharacteristically fretful wife, were met with the ominous response: “Then I know now why I’m frightened – because that is flying in the face of God.”

When she entered the “very lovely” second-class cabin onboard, Esther insisted that she would not go to bed at night on the ship and instead would sleep in the day.

Eva believes that this irrational reaction may have saved their lives. On the Titanic’s last night: “At ten to 12, sitting there sewing, she felt a bump.”

Her mother said it felt like pulling into a train station. It was, of course, the iceberg.

Other passengers on the port side barely felt what happened, but the Harts were able to make their escape quickly because Esther was awake to hear it.

“If my mother had been asleep the night the Titanic hit an iceberg, I wouldn’t be here. There is absolutely no question about that,” Eva said.

She remembers her father putting on a thick coat then: “He just swooped me up in his arms with a thick blanket on me.”

Of course, the Titanic had 2,200 passengers but only enough space on lifeboats for 800: “The people who were there first as we were, were able to get onto a lifeboat, and the people who were roused later and came up on deck, there was no lifeboat for them. So 1,516 of them had to wait two hours to die, because she took two and a half hours to sink.”

“So he put us in a lifeboat and stood back to help other women and children, and made no attempt to get in, and he just said to me “hold Mummy’s hand and be a good girl,” and that was the last I ever saw of him.”

Over the course of her life, Eva was a singer in Australia and a magistrate in Ilford for 20 years. She was awarded an MBE, and was involved with many films and documentaries about the Titanic, including A Night To Remember. There’s even a pub named in her honour.

The CD of the talk is for sale for £4 from the Archives and Local Studies Centre at Valence House, and on eBay. It can also be borrowed from Valence Library.


Welcome , please leave your message below.

Optional - JPG files only
Optional - MP3 files only
Optional - 3GP, AVI, MOV, MPG or WMV files

Please log in to leave a comment and share your views with other Barking and Dagenham Post visitors.

We enable people to post comments with the aim of encouraging open debate.

Only people who register and sign up to our terms and conditions can post comments. These terms and conditions explain our house rules and legal guidelines.

Comments are not edited by Barking and Dagenham Post staff prior to publication but may be automatically filtered.

If you have a complaint about a comment please contact us by clicking on the Report This Comment button next to the comment.

Not a member yet?

Register to create your own unique Barking and Dagenham Post account for free.

Signing up is free, quick and easy and offers you the chance to add comments, personalise the site with local information picked just for you, and more.

Sign up now

Latest Barking and Dagenham News Stories

Yesterday, 16:35

Hundreds of teenagers heard tales from the working world at a special careers fair.

Yesterday, 16:17

Council tax bills are set to rise and street cleaning could be cut back as the town hall tightens its belt to save £63million by 2021.

Yesterday, 14:38

A Dagenham car thief who caused a crash that left three people with life-changing injuries as he fled the scene of a burglary has been jailed for seven years.

Yesterday, 14:09

Pet owners in Dagenham are being taught how to make a dog’s dinner of their Christmas grub.

Yesterday, 12:00

A group of aspiring lawyers from Barking and Dagenham College took part in a mock murder case to develop their arguing skills.

Yesterday, 10:00

The number of secondary schools in Barking and Dagenham to be rated good or outstanding by Ofsted has decreased in the past year.

Yesterday, 08:48

A woman whose tumble dryer caught fire after exploding late at night had to leave her bungalow in the early hours of this morning.

Yesterday, 08:09

A campaign to tackle food waste and homelessness in the borough this winter has been launched.


The festive season is a hectic time for many, with frenzied dashes to the shops for groceries and gifts, and parties to arrange and attend.

You don’t have to make the trek to the North Pole to get into the Christmas spirit this year.

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Most read news

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Barking and Dagenham Post
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now